Yes, one should not generalize (opps, I'm generalizing again ;-) and you make very strong observations. However unlike conventional ICE vehicles, the 2023+ outlander PHEV is engineered to no-start under frigid temperature conditions (say < -25C) leaving the owner stranded. Moreover, this was a deliberate decision made by Mitsubishi as previous models of the PHEV had workarounds built into the battery system - a battery heater to maintain a traction battery start condition. This doesn't, on the face of it, appear to be difficult issue to overcome. They could have:
1) Retained the traction battery heater (even as an optional extra),
2) Installed a conventional ICE/Lead Acid battery starter,
3) Considered a limp mode start ICE only condition for the traction battery to provide a short term current burst only to start the ICE (assuming it doesn't damage the battery).
In addition, they could have redirected some of the "waste heat" of the ICE to warm the traction battery after the ICE is started to bring the battery up to an operational state quickly (perhaps they already do this - not sure). I believe that they redirect the heat pump to cool the battery in the heat of summer to control the battery's temperature.
Your observation that Toronto/Montreal do not experience these extreme temperatures is valid if you live in those areas and don't intent to travel to locations such as northern Ontario, the prairies, mountains etc. Alberta typically sees these cold temperatures a few days-weeks throughout the winter. I've experienced temperatures on the TransCanada over Lake Superior where my Lead Acid battery froze overnight (Thunder Bay) and then during the drive that day (Wawa) to Toronto, the carburetor iced up and I had to idle on the highway to prevent an engine stall until the ice melted away. I can't imagine considering the use of the PHEV under these conditions but those who live in these areas cope with battery blankets, block heaters etc. They have options with an ICE - it appears that we don't.
Again, as an aside, I find all of this quite ironic given that the dealer INSISTED on my purchase of the overpriced pre-installed "Alberta Winter Package" consisting of a block heater, floor mats and mud guards (to enhance rust
) to insure trouble free winter operation of the car ignoring the fact that the car would not start even if the ICE was nice and warm.
We really should have been informed of this situation prior to purchase. It is not reasonable to expect that a buyer would understand the environmental conditions that prevent the use of the car a-priori. Mitsubishi should (have) provide(d) an optional traction battery heater (similar to a block heater) if they didn't want to add to the cost of the vehicle. In this case, I would only have myself to blame. BTW, I still like the car - great value except for this down side.